Evangelista vs. Santos
[GR L-1721, 19 May 1950] En Banc, Reyes (J): 6 concur Facts: Juan
! E"an#e$%s&a, e&! a$! are '%nor%&y s&oco$*ers o+ &e %&a$% %&a$% Lu'er .o'/any, nc!,
a %$%//%ne cor/ora&%on or#an%e* +or &e e3/$o%&a&%on o+ a $u'er concess%on %n 4a'oan#a, %$%//%nes, %$e Ra+ae$ an&os o$*s 'ore &an 50 o+ &e s&ocs o+ sa%* cor/ora&%on an* a$so %s an* a$ays as een &e /res%*en&, 'ana#er, an* &reasurer &ereo+! an&os, %n suc &r%/$e ca/ac%&y, &rou# +au$&, ne#$ec&, an* aan*on'en& a$$oe* %&s $u'er concess%on &o $a/se an* %&s /ro/er&%es an* asse&s, a'on# &e' 'ac%ner%es, u%$*%n#s, areouses, &rucs, e&c!, &o *%sa//ear, *%sa//ear, &us caus%n# &e co'/$e&e ru%n o+ &e cor/ora&%on an* &o&a$ *e/rec%a&%on o+ %&s s&ocs! E"an#e$%s&a, e&! a$! &ere+ore /rays +or 8u*#'en& reu%r%n# an&os: (1) &o ren*er an accoun& o+ %s a*'%n%s&ra&%on o+ &e cor/ora&e a++a%rs an* asse&s: (2) &o /ay /$a%n&%++s &e "a$ue o+ & e%r res/ec&%"e /ar&%c%/a&%on %n sa%* asse&s on &e as%s o+ &e "a$ue o+ &e s&ocs e$* y eac o+ &e' an* (;) &o /ay &e cos&s o+ su%&! E"an#e$%s&a, e&! a$! a$so as +or suc o&er re'e*y as 'ay e an* eu%&a$e! <e co'/$a%n& *oes no& #%"e E"an# e$%s&a, e&! a$!=s res%*ence, u&, u& /ur/oses o+ "enue, a$$e#es &a& an&os res%*es a& 2112 eey Bou$e"ar*, corner L%er&a* &ree&, asay, /ro"%nce o+ R%a$! >a"%n# een ser"e* %& su''ons a& &a& /$ace, an&os +%$e* a 'o&%on +or &e *%s'%ssa$ o+ &e co'/$a%n& on &e #roun* o+ %'/ro/er "enue an* a$so on &e #roun* &a& &e co'/$a%n& *%* no& s&a&e a cause o+ ac&%on %n +a"or o+ E"an#e$%s&a, e&! a$! ?+&er ear%n#, &e $oer cour& ren*ere* %&s or*er, #ran&%n# &e 'o&%on +or *%s'%ssa$! Recons%*era&%on o+ &e or*er as *en%e*! E"an#e$%s&a, e&! a$! a//ea$e* &o &e u/re'e .our&! Issue: @e&er
E"an#e$%s&a, e&! a$! a* &e r%#& &o r%n# &e ac&%on +or *a'a#es resu$&%n# +ro'
'%s'ana#e'en& o+ &e a++a%rs an* asse&s o+ &e cor/ora&%on y %&s /r%nc%/a$ o++%cer, %& e%n# a$$e#e* &a& an&os= 'a$a*'%n%s&ra&%on as rou#& aou& &e ru%n o+ &e cor/ora&%on an* &e conseuen& $oss o+ "a$ue o+ %&s s&ocs! Held: <e
%n8ury co'/$a%ne* o+ %s /r%'ar%$y &o &e cor/ora&%on, so &a& &e su%& +or &e *a'a#es
c$a%'e* sou$* e y &e cor/ora&%on ra&er &an y &e s&oco$*ers! <e s&oco$*ers 'ay no& *%rec&$y c$a%' &ose *a'a#es +or &e'se$"es +or &a& ou$* resu$& %n &e a//ro/r%a&%on y, an* &e *%s&r%u&%on a'on# &e' o+ /ar& o+ &e cor/ora&e asse&s e+ore &e *%sso$u&%on o+ &e cor/ora&%on
an* &e $%u%*a&%on o+ %&s *e&s an* $%a%$%&%es, so'e&%n# %c canno& e $e#a$$y *one %n "%e o+ sec&%on 16 o+ &e .or/ora&%on La, %c /ro"%*es &a& Ao sa$$ cor/ora&%on sa$$ 'ae or *ec$are any s&oc or on* *%"%*en* or any *%"%*en* a&soe"er +ro' &e /ro+%&s ar%s%n# +ro' %&s us%ness, or *%"%*e or *%s&r%u&e %&s ca/%&a$ s&oc or /ro/er&y o&er &an ac&ua$ /ro+%&s a'on# %&s 'e'ers or s&oco$*ers un&%$ a+&er &e /ay'en& o+ %&s *e&s an* &e &er'%na&%on o+ %&s e3%s&ence y $%'%&a&%on or $a+u$ *%sso$u&%on!A Bu& %$e %& %s &o &e cor/ora&%on &a& &e ac&%on sou$* /er&a%n %n cases o+ &%s na&ure, oe"er, %+ &e o++%cers o+ &e cor/ora&%on, o are &e ones ca$$e* u/on &o /ro&ec& &e%r r%#&s, re+use &o sue, or ere a *e'an* u/on &e' &o +%$e &e necessary su%& ou$* e +u&%$e ecause &ey are &e "ery ones &o e sue* or ecause &ey o$* &e con&ro$$%n# %n&eres& %n &e cor/ora&%on, &en %n &a& case any one o+ &e s&oco$*ers %s a$$oe* &o r%n# su%&! Bu& %n &a& case %& %s &e cor/ora&%on %&se$+ an* no& &e /$a%n&%++ s&oco$*er &a& %s &e rea$ /ro/er&y %n %n&eres&, so &a& suc *a'a#es as 'ay e reco"ere* sa$$ /er&a%n &o &e cor/ora&%on! n o&er or*s, %& %s a *er%"a&%"e su%& rou#& y a s&oco$*er as &e no'%na$ /ar&y /$a%n&%++ +or &e ene+%& o+ &e cor/ora&%on, %c %s &e rea$ /ro/er&y %n %n&eres&! >ere%n, E"an#e$%s&a, e&! a$! a"e rou#& &e ac&%on no& +or &e ene+%& o+ &e cor/ora&%on u& +or &e%r on ene+%&, s%nce &ey as &a& an&os 'ae #oo* &e $osses occas%one* y %s '%s'ana#e'en& an* /ay &o &e' &e "a$ue o+ &e%r res/ec&%"e /ar&%c%/a&%on %n &e cor/ora&e asse&s on &e as%s o+ &e %r res/ec&%"e o$*%n#s! .$ear$y, &%s canno& e *one un&%$ a$$ cor/ora&e *e&s, %+ &ere e any, are /a%* an* &e e3 %s&ence o+ &e cor/ora&%on &er'%na&e* y &e $%'%&a&%on o+ %&s car&er or y $a+u$ *%sso$u&%on %n "%e o+ &e /ro"%s%ons o+ sec&%on 16 o+ &e .or/ora&%on La! & resu$&s &a& E"an#e$%s&a, e&! a$!=s co'/$a%n& sos no cause o+ ac&%on %n &e%r +a"or!
