Gia ES 108
Febie
S.
De
Asis
BSEnE-V
Case Study 2. R.E. Construction: t!s "o# or "e$er Su%%ary En&ineer Ro%eo Ro%eo Estabi''o (nis)ed )is Ci$i' en&ineerin& course at *A+,A institute o tec)no'o&y too )is bored e/a%ination in 181 and assed it. e #ent bac to )is )o%eto#n Santia&o City to &et )is o#n construction (r%. e )ired 2 assistant to )e' )i%3 one o )is assistants *r. Si'$ino Santia&o3 #)o is a 4rd year ci$i' en&ineerin& student #)o )ad sto because o (nancia' di5cu'ties. e is a drats %an3 )is duty #as to roduce a'' docu%ents retai'in& to t)e )ysica' re6ui e6uirre%en e%ents ts o t)e t)e $ari $ariou ous s cont contra ract cts s a'so a'so assi assist stin in& & en&i en&ine neer er Esta Estabi bi'' ''o o in suer$isin& #orers on $arious construction site. 7)e second assistant *r. *r. Ra%u'o *a%ari' #as assi&ned to coordinate coordinate urc)asin& urc)asin& and ot)er ad%inistrati$e acti$ities. At t)e t)ird year o oerations3 En&ineer Estabi''o )e oerates )is ne#'y constructed constructed o5ce on )is residentia' co%ound 2 %ore e%a'e e%'oyees #as )ired. n 1 En&ineer Estabi''o re$ie#ed )is co%any!s ayro'' )e )as si/ u''-ti%e ci$i' en&ineers 2 drats%en3 10 ad%inistrati$e ersonne' 1 %essen&er and 1 security &uard. By 9une 1 En&ineer Estabi''o Estabi''o e't t)at business #as continuous'y continuous'y &ro#in& a'so )e ee's t)at )e %ay not be ab'e to eror% )is unctions e;ecti$e'y i )e #i'' us) t)rou&) #it) t)e 'an3 )e t)ins oerations are no# %ore co%'e/ t)at decision %ain& is a %ust .
7)e +rob'e%
7)e rob'e% in t)is case is t)e %anner En&ineer A sea' 'ans t)at )as not been reared by )i% or #)ic) )e )as not c)eced and re$ie#ed in detai'. t is because o t)e si
2. )e deci decide ded d to us) us) t)ro t)rou& u&) ) #it) #it) t)e t)e 'an 'an o addi addin& n& our our u'' u''-t -ti% i%e e ci$i ci$i'' en&ineers3 #i'' )e be ab'e to eror% )is unctions e;ecti$e'y> . A'ternati$e Courses o Action. 1. *ae a decision #)et)er to e%'oy our u''-ti%e ci$i' en&ineers or not.
2. Ater %ain& a decision3 stri$e %ore to be ab'e to eror% )is unctions e;ecti$e'y. V. 9usti(cation o t)e c)osen a'ternati$e Ater ana'ysin& t)e situation o En&ineer Ro%eo Estabi''o3 su&&est t)at )e3 bein& t)e o#ner o )is o#n construction (r%3 s)ou'd (rst en)ance )is decision-%ain& si'' in order to %ae )is business %ore e5cient'y oerationa'. As t)e )ead o a continuous'y &ro#in& co%any3 )e s)ou'd be co%etent enou&) to no# #)at action to tae in any circu%stances.
Case Ana'ysis ?R.E Construction: t!s no# or ne$er@
A. Situationer Bac&round 7)e act in t)is case raise so%e o t)e %ost unda%enta' 6uestions concernin& t)e %anner in #)ic) en&ineerin& (r%s en&a&e in t)e ractice o roession.
+rob'e% State%ent 7)e rob'e% in t)is case is t)e %anner En&ineer A sea' 'ans t)at )as not been reared by )i% or #)ic) )e )as not c)eced and re$ie#ed in detai'
+rob'e% Ana'ysis Because o t)e si
B. Assu%tions nsu5cient nu%ber o En&ineers t)at )a$e aut)ority to sea' and si&n t)e docu%ents
C. A'ternati$e Course o Action +roessiona' En&ineer %ay et)ica''y sea' a'' t)e docu%ents t)ey reared and assu%e 'e&a' resonsibi'ity on'y or t)at in #)ic) )e ossesses understandin& and co&ni
D. Reco%%endation En&ineer A or t)e c)ie En&ineer s)a'' &i$e a detai'ed re$ie# and c)ec t)e desi&n o t)e ro=ect and 'ans reared by )is re&istered en&ineer. +roessiona' en&ineer t)at #or under t)e suer$ision o C)ie En&ineer %ay a'so sea' and si&n t)eir reared docu%ents as 'on& as t)ey )a$e a roer orientation and trainin&. *ay consider )irin& additiona' C)ie En&ineer t)at #i'' si&n and sea' re$ie#ed docu%ents.