REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES NATIONAL CAPITAL JUDICIAL REGION METROPOLITAN METROPOLITAN TRIAL COURT City of Valenzuela Branch ____
DANILO M. OSCARES, e!e"ente# $y %i" &ife' EMILIA O. OSCARES, Plaintiff' Civil Case No. _________ Re,o)ey y of O&ne O&ne"% "%i! i! an an# # For Re,o)e ()e"u"( Po""e""ion &it% Da-a.e" LOURDES A. ENALAS,
Defen#ant * +((((((((((((((((((((+
COMPLAINT COMES NO!, !laintiff DANILO M. OSCARES' e!e"ente# $y %e &ife' EMILIA O. OSCARES' an# a""i"te# $y t%e Pu$li, Attoney/" Offi,e' unto t%i" Honoa$le Cout' -o"t e"!e,tfully "tate" t%at0 PARTIES
1* Plaintiff Danilo 2* O",ae" i" a Fili!ino' of le.al a.e' -aie# an# a e"i#ent of No* 131 San,%ez St*' A4on. Bato' Valenzuela City &%ee %e -ay $e "e)e# &it% noti,e"' o#e" an# ot%e !o,e""e" $y t%e Honoa$le Cout* He i" e!e"ente# $y %i" &ife' E-ilia O* O",ae"' a Fili!ino' of le.al a.e' a. e' -a -a ie ie# # an an# # a e"i e"i#e #ent nt at t%e t%e "a-e "a-e a# a## #e" e""" a" t%at t%at of !lai !laint ntif iff f t%ou.% a 5S!e,ial Po&e of Attoney6 7%eeto 7%eeto atta,%e# a" Anne" #A$ 8* 8* T%e fa,t of t%e ,ele$ation of t%ei -aia.e on 9 June 1:;< i" "u!!ote# $y a !%oto" !%oto"tat tati, i, ,o!y ,o!y of t%ei t%ei 52aia.e Conta,t6 ' &%i,% &a" i""ue# $y t%e P%ili!!ine Stati"ti," Aut%oity 7%eeto atta,%e# a" Anne" #B$ 8= 8= 3* Defen#ant Lou#e" A* Enala" i" li4e&i"e a Fili!ino' of le.al a.e' &i#o& an# a e"i#ent of No* 13> San,%ez St*' A4on. Bato' Valenzuela City &%ee "%e -ay $e "e)e# &it% noti,e"' o#e" an# ot%e !o,e""e" $y t%e Honoa$le Cout= FACTUAL ANTECEDENTS AND CAUSES OF ACTION
9* On 3; De,e-$e 3?1@' !laintiff $ou.%t a !a,el of lan# "ituate# at Blo,4 :' Lot 1;' San,%ez St*' A4on. Bato' Valenzuela City' &%i,% %a" a total lot aea of a!!o+i-ately 19@ "uae -ete"' fo- t%e 5Pina.(I"an. Da-#a-in n. A4on.(Bato' In,*6 7PIDABI8' 7PIDABI8' an a""o,iation #uly o.anize# an# e+i"tin. un#e an# $y )itue of t%e la&" of t%e P%ili!!ine" an# %ol#"
offi,e at 2* Uutia St*' A4on. Bato' Valenzuela City* T%e "ai# !a,el of lan# i" e.i"tee# un#e t%e Toen" "y"te- an# i" ,o)ee# $y Tan"fe Cetifi,ate of Title No* V(:19?1* T%e "ale i" e)i#en,e# $y a #uly notaize# 5Dee# of A$"olute Sale6 7%eeto atta,%e# a" Anne"es #C$ %o C&'$ 8= <* In )ie& of t%e afoe-entione# "ale' Tan"fe Cetifi,ate of Title No* V(:19?1 &a" ,an,elle# an# Tan"fe Cetifi,ate of Title No* ?19( 3?1???@:@ &a" i""ue# in t%e na-e of %eein !laintiff 7%eeto atta,%e# a" Anne"es #D$ %o #D&'$ 8= @* On 1 Se!te-$e 3?1' a 5Veifi,ation Plan6 of Lot" 1@ to 9<' Blo,4 :' P,"(19(??3< in San,%ez St*' A4on. Bato' Valenzuela City &a" !e!ae# $y Geo#eti, En.* Jay S* Pei#a fo PIDABI 7%eeto atta,%e# a" Anne" #E$ 8* In a,,o#an,e t%ee&it%' #efen#ant' &%o i" a""i.ne# at Blo,4 :' Lot 1:' San,%ez St*' A4on. Bato' Valenzuela City' en,oa,%e# on t%e !o!ety of %eein !laintiff' &%i,% i" lo,ate# at Blo,4 :' Lot 1;' San,%ez St*' A4on. Bato' Valenzuela City* T%e en,oa,%e# aea i" nineteen 71:8 "uae -ete"' -oe o le""= * Ina"-u,% a" !laintiff an# #efen#ant e"i#e in t%e "a-e $aan.ay !laintiff/" &ife' E-ilia O* O",ae"' t%en in"titute# a ,o-!laint in t%e Offi,e of t%e Punon. Baan.ay of Baan.ay A4on. Bato' Valenzuela City* A "eie" of %eain." &ee t%en ,on#u,te# t%ou.% t%e inte,e""ion of t%e !an.4at an# t%e lu!on in t%e "ai# $aan.ay* Ne)et%ele""' t%e !atie" faile# to -u"te a ,o-!o-i"e* T%e ,etifi,ate to file a,tion' a" &ell a" t%e noti,e" an# -inute" of all t%e %eain."' &%i,% &ee %el# $efoe t%e lu!on' ae %eeto atta,%e# a" Anne"es #F$ %o #F&'($ = >* E-ilia O* O",ae" "ou.%t le.al a""i"tan,e fo- t%e Pu$li, Attoney/" Offi,e elati)e to %e #e"ie to e,o)e t%e o&ne"%i! an# !o""e""ion of t%e aea en,oa,%e# $y t%e #efen#ant* Plaintiff an# #efen#ant &ee in)ite# to atten# !e(liti.ation ,onfeen,e on 3 2ay 3?1>' < 2ay 3?1>' ; 2ay 3?1> an# 11 2ay 3?1>' a" e)i#en,e# $y noti,e" t%eefo &%i,% ae %eeto atta,%e# a" Anne"es #)$ %o #)&*$ * T%e "a-e &a" un"u,,e""ful' %o&e)e' a" at t%at ti-e t%e !atie" ,oul# not ai)e at an a-i,a$le "ettle-ent* T%i" !o-!te# t%e tan"-ittal of a #e-an# lette 7%eeto atta,%e# a" Anne" #+$ 8 t%ou.% e.i"tee# -ail to t%e #efen#ant on 3 2ay 3?1>* Sai# lette &a" e,ei)e# $y t%e #efen#ant %e"elf $a"e# on t%e e.i"ty etun t%eefo' a" &ell a" a ,etifi,ation fo- t%e Valenzuela Cental Po"t Offi,e 7%eeto atta,%e# a" Anne"es #I$ an# #,$ ' e"!e,ti)ely8= ;* On 1 June 3?1>' E-ilia O* O",ae" an# t%e #efen#ant a!!eae# ane& $efoe t%e Pu$li, Attoney/" Offi,e to fo-alize in &itten fo- t%ei )e$al a.ee-ent &it% e"!e,t to t%e #i"!ute# !o!ety* On t%e "a-e #ate' t%e !atie" t%en "i.ne# a 5a"un#uan6 7%eeto atta,%e# a" Anne"es #-$ %o #-&.$ 8 in a,,o#an,e &it% &%i,% t%e #efen#ant' on one %an#' a.ee# to %a)e t%e &all of %e %ou"e ,olla!"e#' an# %a)e it e$uilt an# !o"itione# "o t%at it &ill no lon.e en,oa,% on t%e !o!ety of t%e !laintiff
&%ile E-ilia O* O",ae"' on t%e ot%e %an#' a.ee# to "%oul#e a total of one t%ou"an# 71'???8 %ollo& $lo,4" fo t%e e,on"tu,tion of #efen#ant/" &all= :* Su$"euently' #efen#ant %a# a ,%an.e of -in#' a""etin. t%at t%e fin#in." in t%e 5Veifi,ation Plan6 ,oul# not $e elie# u!on a" it #iffee# &it% t%e e"ult of t%e lan# "u)ey &%i,% &a" alle.e#ly !e)iou"ly ,o--i""ione# $y PIDABI= 1?* T%u"' on 1: June 3?1>' a final #e-an# lette 7%eeto atta,%e# a" Anne+ 5L68 &a" "ent to t%e #efen#ant at %e .i)en a##e"" t%ou.% e.i"tee# -ail* T%i" &a" e,ei)e# $y %e "on' Jo%n 2a4 A* Enala"' on 3; June 3?1>' a" e)i#en,e# $y t%e e.i"ty etun t%efo' a" &ell a" a ,etifi,ation fo- t%e Valenzuela Cental Po"t Offi,e 7%eeto atta,%e# a" Anne"es #M$ an# #N$ ' e"!e,ti)ely8* Ba"e# on t%e final #e-an# lette t%e #efen#ant &a" .i)en a non(e+ten#i$le !eio# of fifteen 71@8 #ay" foe,ei!t t%eeof &it%in &%i,% to ,o-!ly &it% t%e a$o)e(a#)ete# 5a"un#uan6 ' ot%e&i"e' an a!!o!iate a,tion "%all $e file# a.ain"t %e in ,out= 11* T%e ui"#i,tion of t%e ,out o)e an a,tion in)ol)in. title to o !o""e""ion of lan# i" #ete-ine# $y t%e a""e""e# )alue t%eeof in a,,o#an,e &it% Se,tion 99 of Bata" Pa-$an"a Bilan. 13:' a" a-en#e# $y Re!u$li, A,t No* >:1' ot%e&i"e 4no&n a" 5 T%e Ju#i,iay Reo.anization A,t of 1:;? 6' a" a-en#e#= 13* T%e a""e""e# )alue of t%e lan# o&ne# $y !laintiff' &%i,% i" "ituate# at Blo,4 :' Lot 1;' San,%ez St*' A4on. Bato' Valenzuela City' fo t%e !eio# ,o)ein. Januay' 3?1> to De,e-$e' 3?1> i" P;'1??*??' in ,on"onan,e &it% t%e 5State-ent of A,,ount6 ' #ate# Januay 3?1>' i""ue# $y t%e Real Po!ety Ta+ Di)i"ion of t%e Offi,e of t%e City Tea"ue of t%e City Go)en-ent of Valenzuela fo %eein !laintiff 7%eeto atta,%e# a" Anne" #O$ 8* T%u"' t%e in"tant a,tion fall" un#e t%e ui"#i,tion of t%e 2eto!olitan Tial Cout of Valenzuela City= 19* A" a e"ult of t%e un&aante# an# unu"tifie# efu"al of t%e #efen#ant to e-o)e t%e en,oa,%-ent on t%e !o!ety o&ne# $y !laintiff t%e latte &a" ,o-!elle# to file t%e in"tant a,tion' to liti.ate an# to in,u e+!en"e" an# ,o"t of "uit* He al"o "uffee# "lee!le"" ni.%t" an# "eiou" an+iety fo &%i,% ea"on %e i" entitle# to -oal #a-a.e" in t%e "u- of P1??'???*??* Fut%e-oe' to "et an e+a-!le to ot%e"' &%o ae "i-ilaly "ituate#' !laintiff i" al"o entitle# e+e-!lay #a-a.e" in t%e a-ount of P@?'???*??= an# 1<* Plaintiff an# E-ilia O* O",ae" ae in#i.ent' a" e)i#en,e# $y ,etifi,ate" of in#i.en,y &%i,% &ee in#i)i#ually i""ue# in t%ei na-e $y t%e 5Tan..a!an n. San..unian. Baan.ay6 of Baan.ay A4on. Bato' Valenzuela City' a" &ell a" t%e Valenzuela City So,ial elfae an# De)elo!-ent Offi,e 7%eeto atta,%e# a" Anne"es #P$ %o #P&*$ 8* T%u"'
t%ey ae e+e-!te# fo- t%e !ay-ent of filin. fee" ,onfo-a$ly &it% Se,tion of Re!u$li, A,t No* :?< &%i,% ea#"0 5T%e ,lient" of t%e PAO "%all e+e-!t fo- !ay-ent of #o,4et an# ot%e fee" in,i#ental to in"titutin. an a,tion in ,out an# ot%e ua"i(u#i,ial $o#ie"' a" an oi.inal !o,ee#in. o on a!!eal*6 T%i" &a" affi-e# in t%e 9? July 3?19 Re"olution in A*2* No* 11(1?(?9(? 7Re0 Lette #ate# A!il 1;' 3?11 of C%ief Pu$li, Attoney Pe"i#a Rue#a(A,o"ta Reue"tin. E+e-!tion fo- t%e Pay-ent of S%eiff/" E+!en"e" 8' &%ee t%e Su!e-e Cout En Ban, ' a-on. ot%e"' ule# t%at ualifie# ,lient" of t%e Pu$li, Attoney/" Offi,e ae e+e-!te# fo- t%e !ay-ent of filin. o #o,4et fee"* PRA/ER !+EREFORE, !e-i"e" ,on"i#ee#' it i" -o"t e"!e,tfully !aye# of t%i" Honoa$le Cout t%at a #e,i"ion $e en#ee# o#ein. t%e #efen#ant" a" follo&"0
a* to #e-oli"% "u,% !otion of t%e i-!o)e-ent "%e ,on"tu,te# on %e lan# an# to a#u"t an# e$uil# "ai# i-!o)e-ent a,,o#in.ly in o#e to e-o)e t%e en,oa,%-ent on t%e lan# o&ne# $y %eein !laintiff= $* to !ay -oal #a-a.e" in t%e a-ount of P1??'???*?? ,* to !ay e+e-!lay #a-a.e" in t%e a-ount of P@?'???*??= an# #* to !ay attoney/" fee"' liti.ation e+!en"e" an# ,o"t of "uit in "u,% a-ount a" t%e ,out -ay a#u#.e* Ot%e elief" #ee-e# u"t an# euita$le un#e t%e foe.oin. !e-i"e" ae li4e&i"e !aye# fo* Valenzuela City' 2eto 2anila' 3? July 3?1>*
EMILIA O. OSCARES Plaintiff/" Re!e"entati)e
A""i"te# $y0 PUBLIC ATTORNE/0S OFFICE 1ALEN2UELA DISTRIC T OFFICE 9RD Floo' Po"t Offi,e Bl#.* Ju"ti,e Hall Co-!oun#' C*J* Santo" St*' Po$la,ion II 2alinta' Valenzuela City
T%ou.%0
ATT/. RAFAEL D. PAN)ILINAN Pu$li, Attoney II
Roll No* <;< IBP No* 1?131>> #ate# 1? Januay 3?1> CAL2ANA A#-itte# to t%e Ba on A!il 3:' 3?1@ 2CLE Co-!lian,e V ??11:@1
Note# $y0
ATT/. DENNIS C. -UON) Pu$li, Attoney III Roll No* @@:>< IBP No* :3@9:; A#-itte# to Ba0 3??; 2CLE Co-!lian,e V ???>:<3
COP/ FURNIS+ED LOURDES A. ENALAS No* 13> San,%ez St*' A4on. Bato' Valenzuela City' 1<<< 2eto 2anila Re.i"ty etun no*0
E3PLANATION
Se)i,e of t%e foe.oin. !etition to t%e #efen#ant &a" -a#e t%ou.% e.i"tee# fo la,4 of !e"onnel to effe,t !e"onal "e)i,e*
ATT/. RAFAEL D. PAN)ILINAN
REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES CIT OF VALENUELA
8 8 S*S*
1ERIFICATION4CERTIFICATION I' EMILIA O. OSCARES' Fili!ino' of le.al a.e' -aie#' an# e"i#ent of No* 131 San,%ez St*' A4on. Bato' Valenzuela City' afte %a)in. $een #uly "&on in a,,o#an,e &it% la&' #e!o"e an# "tate t%at0 1* I a- t%e e!e"entati)e of t%e !laintiff in t%e a$o)e(,a!tione# ,a"e= 3* I ,au"e# t%e !e!aation of t%e foe.oin. ,o-!laint= 9* I ea# t%e fa,tual alle.ation" t%eein ,ontaine# an# t%e "a-e ae tue an# ,oe,t of -y o&n !e"onal 4no&le#.e an# on t%e $a"i" of t%e !etinent e,o#" -a#e a)aila$le to -e= an# <* I fut%e ,etify t%at I %a)e not ,o--en,e# any ot%e a,tion o !o,ee#in. in)ol)in. t%e "a-e i""ue in t%e Su!e-e Cout' t%e Cout of A!!eal"' o t%e #iffeent #i)i"ion" t%eeof' o any ot%e ti$unal o a.en,y an# t%at to t%e $e"t of -y 4no&le#.e' no "u,% a,tion o !o,ee#in. i" !en#in. in t%e Su!e-e Cout' t%e Cout of A!!eal"' o t%e #iffeent #i)i"ion" t%eeof' o any ot%e ti$unal o a.en,y= an# t%at if I "%oul# lean t%at a "i-ila a,tion i" !en#in. $efoe t%e Su!e-e Cout' t%e Cout of A!!eal"' o t%e #iffeent #i)i"ion" t%eeof' o any ot%e ti$unal o a.en,y' I &ill notify t%e Honoa$le Cout &it%in fi)e 7@8 #ay" fo- "u,% noti,e*
EMILIA O. OSCARES Affiant SUBSCRIBED AND S!ORN to $efoe -e t%i" 1 t% #ay of July 3?1> at t%e City of Valenzuela afte affiant e+%i$ite# to -e %e ,o-!etent e)i#en,e of i#entity $y &ay of Valenzuela City Offi,e of t%e Senio Citizen Affai" i#entifi,ation ,a# &it% ,ontol no* <;3@:' &%i,% &a" i""ue# on 3? Fe$uay 3?1@*
ATT/. RAFAEL D. PAN)ILINAN Pu$li, Attoney II Pu"uant to RA :*
