TMMOB İNŞAAT MÜHENDİSLERİ ODASI İZMİR ŞUBESİ
İLERİ SAP2000 YAPI SİSTEMLERİNİN ANALİZİ Bölüm I 03-04 Şubat 2007 Cumartesi – Pazar
Y. Doç. Dr. Kutlu Darılmaz İTÜ İnşaat Fakültesi Betonarme Yapılar Çalışma Grubu
[email protected] www.ins.itu.edu.tr/kutlu
%
&
&
'
$
' #
&
"
("
"" "
)
* " "% * "
(
!" # $ % &$ ' ()* ( +, ( " $ , /01 ()2 ', ( (, 3 " ,-. /0" (" " 1 ,-. -.* "
' +
-
+,
2
$, ,* "3
.,&,
!
4#
. 0","
&
α $ # '
"1 /α25
"""&
"
4"
"
.0","
0" ,(,
/
* 2
2
P M33 M22
1 i
P
j
2 1
i
3
j
M33
j
M22
1 i
1
V2
i
3
j
V2
j
V3
1
V3
i
Ti
2 1
j
T
1 !"
6 " " " " 0, )) " "3 4 . 0" / 10 -( 10
" "
"
) ) -
&, ,' "2
2 + ".
." " "
" (
6 . ""
1" 6 "
. " ( "" . " (" 10 .3
2 !"
4
kiri
kiri
rijit eleman
perde
perde
EI,GJ büyük
perde kesiti
7 3 ,., "2 " % % "" & >& 6 . ? 5 "* ( ""
"3
" " =
" 6*
"
" ( ()
" = " ,., ( , " 6* ,
83 . % /9: ) ;< ( " " % ( " " " (" " (
" (" @A
" " "
"
Sonlu Eleman Modeli
hkat
y
z
x
EI,GJ büyük
Çubuk eleman Modeli
3 !"
Sonlu Eleman Modeli h kat
" •
1, , "
"
- " . 0"
" " . 1" "* 3 •
"
"
"".
-
,
*
"
"
* (" " 3
B 1
"
. .
3
.
" ("
" 3)
-
C
1 " "
• "
0,"
/
*
"*
=
.3
8 0,
"
1.
" (2
63 3
6 " 1
"
*.
0
-
"
.
2
"
"
)" % •
" "
"" 6 (
*
"
. 0"
0," ,- 3
"
/
.3
" "
"
" . 1" "
8
.3
1
/D8 E)2 .
3
6
1 3
, 100","
"
•
9 * (" ( ) )
• •
)" % 0, ," . (
"
(
"
"
"
= " ." . ("" (" 10 6 . . 0, ,
"
"
" 8
Dü eyde 6 parça
Dü eyde 4 parça
C
Uygun olmayan Sonlu Eleman Modeli
3 " -( 01 " " " ("" , ( ( 1 = -" " " ,(, " "" (" ! )F B ,. 0 05 6# ! , ! "( " " " ( "" ("
(. 4
G" 5 0, , ( ,(, " (" ? 5
HIJ B
"
" ("" ""
0.
0
"
4 !"
7
1
47
!,$ 1 ',
#!
7
7
! $, ! '
4
, '#(
'
, 893 :;83 <3 :"
Rθ
Ly
Rv Lx +0 . K) = ⋅ 0" .
K θ. =
" = ⋅ LJ ⋅ L. -
"
⋅ :M =
⋅
' L. ⋅ L J
& " " .3 " " " " , .3 6 ,. ,.* 2
9
"
"
!,$ 1 ',
#!
• • • •
"*
K θJ =
⋅ : M# =
( 0" . 6 4 0"
" " "
.
"
) $,! '
⋅
(
, '#(
' LJ ⋅ L .
& (" " " / Kθ / ? " .3""
"
'
" 3 "10
,. → = ' >6 & → ,
(
(-
) . 0"
, 893 :;83 <3 :"
M - . 1 " . 3 . 0,", / N 1 7 ,(, " " ,-. ( .. . OJI J 8HF J 2 . ". , ( 01 " .. . " M - ( " " " "" )F J
.
6 1" 6 3.3 2 6
2 1"→ < " → 3 "1
/H
" 1
"
?, . 3 3 3
<3 :"
5 !"
k1 A k1
5
.
1 &P
7
" ""
3
..
.
")
&
3 " -* 1 ) * " ,. , 1 1 . "
" " 9" ,. , 0 ( 6 3" " "
" 0 . . "" 3 " ( . " . ( 3 = ( " " ". 1 " " ,, 1 "" . 3 ( "
σPδ "
/ 1
•
σ
JPδ
•
σ
"Pδ
5 ;QR σ 8
, J
"
"
2
≥
18 1"
. →
) ;QRQ9 & N σ 8
≤σ8
1 ',
,. →
"
?, . 3 3 3
#
N &N
@ $ >'AB
S& S SN SO
<3 :"
6
!"
C #, ! ? , .
?, .
)+)' #$!
,%,
, ,%,
!
!
'
'
'
'
"
"
7
!"
D
E
F F G 7
3 3
"
3
(
."
"
" "" , ,"
) ) 2--
=
T
3
.
"
"
. " 7#? ' *( +
" * ? '
") 100"," )$)
!
""
/.3""
"
"5
.3 ( (
H PT
/M&2
(
"" 3
)T
K
?
T=
T =&
( /"
6
. ,
. 2
3
,,"
6
6
. ,
" . ,
"
" .3 3" 10
7 ""
"
. , ,"
(-" "
"
. 3
"
("" ,,
T P;Q"R
/M&25= "*
(
/M&2P 59
- 3 . :
". )
M& B
-1 " 3
.
/M&2 . 3
=01 & ' U
:5= " 0" 3
)
U ' &
. . 5 /M2 " -
")
"
MB . / "2
(
--
6
3"
/ ≤M≤M 2
/M2P&Q& N M M
/M ≤M≤M=2
/M2P N /M2P N /M= M2
( 3 .
F
/M>M=2
8
!"
/M2 N
N/M= M2
F
&
M 3
.
M
=
/M 8 M =2
$
" "4
M / "2 & &N &N
$& $ $' $U K5
3
. ,, K
"
. " "M -.*
--
M= / "2 ' U O V
) "-
. K)
(
- 3 .
MB .
(
"5
K P & N + /K − & N2
M M
/ ≤M≤M 2
K PK
M 3
/M>M 2
- (
3
-
. ,, "
"
."
3
. ,
"" 3
-
5 ?
H P∆C?Q
C =&
= " ""?
" / 3 "2
∆C?P
IN ? H
M 3
- (
-
(
3
."
. , ,","∆C?
3
-"
"
. , ,∆C?
?
6
,
"
" -
5 C P/H S∆C?2
T ⋅7 ?
T% ⋅ 7 % % =&
9
!"
3 1
"
& ' U
9- (
3
,
0"
+0,
"
*
5
-
3
1 1 ,
" " -"
0 0 . ,
" " "" " " " " " ?
N
3)
(
""
T=
"
T =&
O I
) "" 1 (
F
1
. 1"
, H PT
( C P/H S∆C?2
" "
/M&2
"
K ) ∆C?P
.". , T ⋅7
"
)
1
IN ? H . ,
( ""
.3 3 .
""
"
"
?
T% ⋅ 7 % % =&
N= O=
, . - * ." (" " ) "- . 1" , " " " ) 1 ( " I= 1 ( H PT /M&2 K ) ∆C?P IN ? H ., "" F= 1 ( H PE T - ( 3 . , "".3 ( (" ) ) . "" " V , " . " "" " " & +0, ,".3 && " /. (8, " ) 2 & = . "
.3 3 . " ""
."
""
"
10
!"
4
D7
G 7
=
. 0" " "6 = .0" " ) 8'
? $!
7 6 "1
)) ) . "6 3 " " "" . (. 0" -
(8 " " 8 )) ( "
.
.
(
-
6
'
B "*
-
" 100"," 3 /M
"*
)
3
"
2 P /M 2 1 K /M 2
" "
3 .
- " /M 2 3
)
.
/M 2 P - " 6 = "
3" .
)
")
/M 2
3
3 /M 2
:
:
P
, ""
:
"
3 .
-" )
3
/M 2 1 K /M 2
5
3 0" . / 3"" 3 " " " " " 1 " . (8 3 " " " " (1 (- " "10 * .2 G " (" 7 " & N8 & U8 " & 5 9 ". ) . / 3"" " ( "* ( "" "* * 3 01 " " (" ( .2 3 01 6 " " ). 3 . 0" (" " "
9M ? 9K H 9 :
M
: :/ 2 3
=01 &
U '
' U /M2
5 3
. /M2 /M2 /M2
/. " P&Q&NM M P N P N /M= M 2 F
& " )
" ( 3 . / ≤M≤M 2 /M W M ≤ M=2 /M X M=2
MB .
(
.2
/M2 N
N/M= M2
F
&
M
M
=
11
!"
3 3 )
.
9 MKD
K
M9K M
.
8M ) M=
9K: $
$
" "4
" " " 01, . " 10 "*
(
M / 2 & &N &N
(
-(
M= / 2 ' U O V
( 3
. 8 K /M28 - 3 . 8MB . (
. ,
." ) "-" 100"," 8 3 ,,
-.*
K /M2 P & N Q /K − & N2 M M K /M2 P K - "
B "
ML K: / M 8M=2
$& $ $' $U 3 -.* 3 ) 0," 3 ,, . 8KB .)
" "4
, 8 .B "
" M -.*
) "-
/ ≤M≤M 2 /M X M 2
"
Hesaba Katılacak Yeterli Titre im Modu Sayısı
7 3
( " " 3 100"," "" ,," -
1 ". "" 6 " 86 , "" YV B " " 3 ( " 100"," "
. 8100"," "6 3 "" 6 " ,
8 "
3
"" " J) .. . " , " 3 ""86 " 10 " .* , "" YNB " " ,., "
Mod Katkılarının Birle tirilmesi
= ". ." 3 3 0 1 ,. ,, 6 3 "" ) " . 1 "* 5 •
M WM M -
•
, M W "
. , ,8 "6 ."
" .
)) 8 ) ) . . 1 " "
8100"," " "6 6 "1 F - " ( "M 3 "" 0,
" - " "M . 1 " " " * " ,," -
(" = 3 "YN
-" 8. , 86
" " 8 / K 2 . 1 "
(-
) 10 " "
( 3 .
" 8 /ERE2 . 1 "* ." . B "" 6 " 8 "
=
" ""
"" " 0",
12
!"
? #. ' $
& '
$ '#( )? ?#2, # , %-2)'( ,2 H $ (' 7 3 " 8 ) "- . 1" , " " ", 4 " →K 3 " 3* C "* " ? Z C "* " /M 2 K /M 2 4 " ." . . " 100"," " " "
13
!"
U
", 4 " →K 3 " " " 3 " :1 = /ERE2 "(
3* E 3 " 6 3 " /G " 5 ) 0", / 3"12
" * . , UJ & NJ VF&PN FFO2 M ( N " "
14
!"
N O
. "- 1 ". E . " .4
( ( " (" 7 -( "
" " * . "/'J
" ,, " 2
" 7
3 100"," .8 0"
"* "" %
15
!"
1
$
7
I
I
J
7,' J, !#
, "
" " "" .3 * 3 6 " 8 • 9" , . - . " • " ") " 4 [ N1 " • ;00"," "* , . 3"" "* ( - 3 . "" N " " ) &N ". " 6 • . -). " -6 ) . " 10 YN 0", " "." " "* 3 ) ( 8 ,,"3 . "8 /M2 P : /M2 " " " /M2 3 ) . ( "" 1 3 "" YV B " "
, " "
= H!,# ) . -
7,' J, !# " "6
. .
"* "" ) S
-) . "
" (
" 8 "
"
-) "*
. "" " "S )
" (
"
-
16
!"
7
.
G"
"
.
( ; -
3
17
!"
,
→
,
→7,' J, !#
5M "
, 6
6
"")
→ ((
. ""
K J, !#
1
1
5
18
!"
M,
$
" 0",
"""YN
, ? → L#K #! = H!,# , #! = H!,# "M " "" 0, "* -" " (( = H!,# 0 L M
( " - "
) ) ""
"
19
!"
#
(
" M
"
) ) ""
"
(-
20
!"
, 3
& ' U
= 9
! !,$ ,!' ,2, ( ,2 &, H $ ( ' ""6 3 0 " " " " " " " ) * " " , " 3 01 " 4 " " 8 " '
" 0
" " .3 G " 5
21
!"
N ;) R . , O .. , ," ( I , " ,
F "
("
"
" . 1" ;QR.,
,
"
3 . , "
"
" "
""
" "
"
" " - . ". .
"
22
!"
V +0,
.3
) "- "*
"
23
!"
1I
4
D
"
-"
7 7 " 3
"")
".,
" 6
γP&F ? φP'
'
#%$& $ '(#%$& $ ) $ & *$' + *+ #%, * - . / (0 ! ' 1 23 $4* $ 0/ &$ . + 2 5+
3 / 25 & 5E π⋅ U 9: = 9 = F OU " " SO ). " * φ = = (& + "φ) \ & = N H=
⋅
!
"
π ⋅ &U = &'IUUUI ? OU && ) ) " "
5
'''
''' = & I ?
/& I + 'I I2 ⋅ O = &&F
\=\ & + O ⋅ &F ⋅
''' = 'I I ?
?
O O& + ( 'I I − & I ) ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ O= ' O+ &O= UOO ? ' ⋅ & & = &' ? = UOO& ⋅ & = I& ' ?
= & I ⋅ O⋅
= &&F
. "" =
U
U9:
=
U
U9:
(-( U ⋅ &'IUUUI = N ⋅&
N
≅' N
24
!"
H/ 2 =
))
)3/
2+
)
/ 2=
"
/ 2
3/
2+
/ 2
J
(CNAEGFIH A 68?:; =:=<> 7<@:=
S X
APRQT SV U Z WY X[
S \
APRQT W S \ U Z
S ]
APRQT W S ] U Z
O ; =L>
687:9<; =<=:>
7 x/lo amp avp amm avm
0 0 -1 -1 0
0.5 -0.2908 -0.2415 -0.8231 0.5816
x kot Poloamp Moamm ΣM M (SAP2000 ) Poavp Moavm/lo ΣV V (SAP2000 )
3
1 -0.3096 0.1108 -0.5083 0.6191
0 -6 0.0 -271.3 -271.3 -271.3 -130.0 0.0 -130.0 -121.41
""
1.5 -0.2226 0.2068 -0.2384 0.4451
1.625 -7.625 -122.9 -223.3 -346.2 -340.52 -31.4 48.6 17.2 18.91
-
2 -0.1231 0.1794 -0.0667 0.2461
2.5 -0.0491 0.1149 0.0166 0.0983
3 -0.007 0.0563 0.0423 0.0141
3.5 0.0106 0.0177 0.0389 -0.0212
3.25 4.875 6.5 8.125 9 -9.25 -10.875 -12.5 -14.125 -15.0 -130.8 -94.0 -52.0 -20.7 -11.2 -137.9 -64.7 -18.1 4.5 8.3 -268.7 -158.7 -70.1 -16.2 -2.9 -254.5 -139.23 -51.03 -6.09 0 14.4 26.9 23.3 14.9 10.8 51.7 37.2 20.5 8.2 4.4 66.1 64.0 43.9 23.1 15.3 70.08 66.43 42.46 15.07 0.98
25
!"
-350 0
-300
-250
-200
-150
-100
-1
-50
0
SAP2000 Analitik
-2 -3 -4 -5 -6 -7 -8 -9
, -150.0
. "*
-100.0
"
-50.0
(-
0.0
50.0
100.0
0 -1 -2
Analitik
-3
SAP2000
-4 -5 -6 -7 -8 -9
,
. " 5$ E
38?
8=
. "*
"
3
) )
(-
" 8 &VVF
26
!"
IE
I
I
J
I
τJ8 JW τ τ.8 JW τ τ 3 ). M ( ). - ) = " )
]
)
N ? &N ? IN ?
27
!"
, ?
τ→ &
0 L#K
/
. " 5 ] 3 ,6 " " 8 U
'
! =# H
!
0 L
2
(" ; -)
3
."
3M
8$ E
38?
8
28
!"
N(
H!,# 6 ! -2
,+, ,
) F
1 3
) IB
"( . " 3 "*
1
H!,# 6 ! 0
" 0, " ("
" " )
" 1 "
,(
9* _ ? ` / F ;,", 2 O I IN F ' ' '' 'U 'O 'I
4* _ ?
I 6I
" "4
= = = = = = = = = =
&U /E&U2 &O/E&O2 &F /E&F2 /E 2 N /E N2 ' /E' 2 'N /E'N2 U /EU 2 UN /EUN2 N /EN 2
4* 5 4* 5 = 4* 5 =
4*
=
" "
4*
%
1" -
" 6* 6*
`
#(,
"
H!,#
",," "
,
9
" 1 "
! ! &
H!,# H ! # H
,(
" 1
"
""
))
1 "
H!,# 6 !
,
* (" ""
-"
"
# !? ! 0, ,"
4* _ ? ` 4* _ ? /γ*P& N "2 V' &' & I &U & &N &' ' &O &OI &F &V '' & OI ' ' '' ' N
N ' 'N U UN N
H!,#
) 3 #(, 6 !
10,
`
" ." ." /4* γ*2 " ."
'N 4*
/=
?
2
/=
?
2
?S
U
,,
.
= " α P& J & + α P& J & = = =
""
&U &O &F
+ &U
" + (9 9P J & N? :
8
-
3
5
" "
9*% = ' N
("
) )
.
"
"
",," " L#K
6 ! =# H
"
= "
,(
H!
<" ;
,. 5 # ?2
"
)
, ?
""
"/ "
."
"" !
H!,#
"
.3
"
H !
" "
,
) I^
"
" "1 3
"*
"
H! ( 4?!,# 3 3 3 ,(
=
H!,#
1
'
; 3
-"
"1 "
* ("
(, '
;
"38 ((
" "5 # ? 0, ," " "
(
.3
1
"(
6 !
-
" * ("
"(
,
. "
(1
""
, ,!,# H!,#
-
,% $ 88 !
SN SN
( ( ,
& E & E 5 N ? ' 5 N VF&P NN
29
!"
" = " 0",
" 3 "≅ N )
=
ν ≅ & OS& N
1PVF&
0",,
&? P& & ? P&? & ?≅& 1 & ?≅ &
30
!"
