Macalintal vs Comelec Case Digest

c
 
c 
 
     !c"  #  "$% & !'()'*Y


  


   +(!
%    % , %  -" .-! /   !01*+! !'()'-% %&-  %  .% &.%  # "&  2(  
3 !0()!1 --% 
c 
 -% &% #  4#& 5"  
  -%# 4#  -
%3
!c
%" %  6
% &% 
 71! !'()'". -&-"&""&  %%  
  % - &%  
c 
(" 84  
3 9 0  &% "  


(! - 7!  -  :!   & "  %    ! 

 

  
  ! "

  #"
  
 !$ % &  

& " 
' "
(  5! !!'()'& &% &%"- 


!5!% 

!; < # "-  -2 -"% *()+% "&" &4"4&! -  2  # =1  --   - 2"-  
!1!)&" !; -% 2&%    + -  & < - # -= + -  &. # < -  &% %%= + -  &&,%   *(+"% - 

&%0 (:>
 

'
"% 
"  &%&  ' 
" *

" 2&   2 % &.&*1+& =' 
"&
"  
$%<,% % ,   &"
 % &.,%= + %- %<   "  ? ."%"&  
%  ?     #   *:+& ? %  !  &   ?  <  !   &  %  %  ?  2&  
! + < # &   # "& # " %& "   2  %! &-"1*+! !!'()'2++   
+


- @%<   @%  A  %!9-&"-%% &% ? .& -  ?     .(7  @""<  #  -2-@. % % " 
% &%= -""   # 2"   
 
% &%! !,
  !   ! 
"  
 - 
+
  
   
 -#"
 ,, 
% & 3

5! !!'()'&  &&& "&4"4&! ()!1  &  
!()! 4
%
&%!; !!!!!!!!! ()!1 &&   -%   -  ! - % %%"
% ++ 
+ *

  

 "+   *

  
     $ "  %   &" " -  &"  
!*  + 
!5!!!  &#4#"  & &"  
%"  # !/ &" #   "    "     9&," 
%"  .   &-"& &!   &%  % & "-   &2 % &"   -    &, c 9 
%"&% !  
% % &% ! !!!  &%& 
% & & -% &4! -   & <- % 5"5"   
 $ 
c 
 -% 4& #4#!5(   " "+  *

  
"()!1! !!'()' -%   -%   &4!  - % 5"5"  
-  &   &#4#   &
%!


% &- 
c 
-  %"" @ -
%&  &&4 - - !@  & 
 -  Y
 

 


    " &% &   -%&4  


%! 
!

      !  "  
  #"
,./ 
% & 3  (! 

"-   " 
&&
" 
 " 
 ! 
!(>!   01"!; (>!(! c"7BB5" 
  <&%   *:+", & 
% &% 
! %-  -%  +C  %-4&& = +C  .   - .&%= +C   "  %& 2-4!  "&% -&-&  6
% &% 
!!!!!!!!!*  +  &&(" 84 %  !   "@, & 
% &% 
@  (>!(-  - 
 <&%    c"7BB5=  "@&-& 6
% &% 
@ %    2&-&&% 7BB5 !
%  &&  - &% -" 
c 
  &(>!(! !!'()'!5)  -"
%-&    
c 
! 

C9    " D  0! -%! !!'()'  0%/
/             

p