MEMO FROM THE STORY DEPT. SECRETS OF STRUCTURE AND CHARACTER
CHRISTOPHER VOGLER &
DAVID MCKENNA
Table of Contents t Acknowledgments Introductio Int roductionn (V (Vogler ogler)) My Time in the Story Deartment (McKenna) Who Are Those Guys? (Vogler) Cp C p 1. You Gotta Ha Have ve a Them hemee (Vogler) Cp Cp 2. The “W “Want” ant” List (McKenna) Cp 3. Wha hat’ t’ss the Big Deal? (Vogler) Cp 4. The Contract with the Audience (Vogler) Cp 5. Polar Oosites (McKenna) Cp C p 6. The Memo Tha hatt Star Started ted It All: A Practical he h ero wiTh wiTh a a T housand housand F aces Guide to T he (Vogler) Cp 7. The Hero’s Inner Journey (Vogler) Cp 8. Recir Recirocal ocal Action (McKenna) Cp 9. Out of Character: The Arc Archetyes hetyes and Other Oth er Ways to Loo Lookk at Character Character (V (Vogle ogler) r) Cp 10. Character: The Algebraic Equa Equation tion (and Other Unnatural Acts) (McKenna) Cp Cp 11. Theoh heohrastus, rastus, Wha hatt a Char Character! acter! (Vogler)
vii
x x x 1 7 13 17 23 29 57 65 71 87 93
Cp 12. The Tools: Synosis and Logline (McKenna) Cp 13. Proing It U: Vladimir Pro’ Pro’ss Fairy Tale Aroach (Vogler) Cp 14. Pro on Character (Vogler) Cp 15. Environment Environmental al Facts: Over Overview view (McKenna) Cp Cp 16. Environ Environmental mental Facts 1: Da Date te (McKenna) Cp 17. Environment Environmental al Facts 2: Loca Location tion (McKenna) Cp 18. Environment Environmental al Facts 3: Social Environment (McKenna) Cp 19. Environment Environmental al Facts 4: Religious Environment (McKenna) Cp 20. Environment Environmental al Facts 5: Political Environment (McKenna) Cp 21. Environment Environmental al Facts : Economic Environment (McKenna) Cp 22. Environment Environmental al Facts: Conclusion (McKenna) Cp Cp 23. What I Lear Learned ned from Vaudevill audevillee (Vogler) Cp 24. Showmanshi (Vogler) Cp 25. Five-Y Five-Year ear Plan for Asiring Professional Screenwriters (McKenna) Cp 26. Wha hatt Studios Are Looking For in a Scrit (Vogler) Cp Cp 27. Fare Thee Well ell:: My Parting Shot (Vogler) About the Authors
viii
113 121 149 153 159 165 173 181 189 197 205 213 229 233 243 251 255
IntroductIon
Who Are Tho hose se Gu Guys? ys? VOGLER
beginning to get on my nerves. nerves. Who are those guys? B C: They’re beginning – p Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid W G
Early versions of Vogler Vogler (left) and McKenna trying to gure it all out at the La Purisima Pur isima Mission in Lompoc, California (photo by Joyce Garrison)
xvii
Memo from the Story Department ~ Vogler & McKenna
I M; D p N J. S W I S. L .. A I , , , , . I I . I j U M , , j U.S. A F. A I L A p p, p K A F B S A, Tx . I , p p p Dial M for Murder . M , D MK. MK , , N J. B , . H , x pp . H B B, , -. D , I, j p p. B I , I p p p, “p ,” , p , ’ ’ . D , . H x ’ ’ ’ ’ p.
xviii
chater one
You Gotta Have A Theme VOGLER
W p , p “W ” T p , z xp . W , N M S pp , . A p Lj Dramatic tic Writing Writing, E, The Art of Drama Macbeth ambition, . Y “O ...” x, , z TV . T ’ , , , p, , . T’ ’ ’ ’ ’ , . W “” “p” , ’ pp - - . . A ’ p p , p . O : X Y . 1
Memo from the Story Department ~ Vogler & McKenna
T ( G) , pp p. P ( L) , pp. A p pp pp , , , , p. I Macbeth , Sp’ p , , . T p p p, . M ’ , ’ . T p “R .” I’ , “A .” H p, “S , p , , pp .” I, , z . I’ p . I p , p . T p , . I . I p xp pp. I - - p , “D’ , ,” - p . A , ’ p, pp p ’ , p p , p p p .
2
You Gotta G otta Have A Theme
T p p. I p p , p . I p p p p. T , . I p I , I’ “I ’ ,” “Y’ ,” “H ” I “” , . I - , ’ . I p, xp . I p “L .” A, , I’ xp p x p. K p . I , ’ , , p , p p, . T , , , pp, z p . F p p ’ p. T , p . B p p,
3
Memo from the Story Department ~ Vogler & McKenna
p p pp p, p, j .
What can we say is the theme of T W , , with its lonely anti-hero who tries to make a go of a normal life but decides it’s his true nature to go out in a heroic blaze of glory? Some have said Redemption; maybe it’s Integrity: To To thine own self se lf be true. What do you think?
SOMETHING TO TO THINK ABOUT
W - W - p I ’ W - W - p D xp , xp p
4
You Gotta G otta Have A Theme
NOTE FROM M cKENNA
S -, I’ C’ . L C, I p . App “” p p p . W I / , p pp p - p. R -- z p ’ . H p , p . W , I . . I . W W ( Anatomy of a Murder , Erin Brockovich The Verdict ppp p) p p p . W p p Erin Brockovich ’ E p, p D erdict t . B M p The Verdic z . M I z. H p ’ xp . B
5
Memo from the Story Department ~ Vogler & McKenna
C p x p I . I , p ’ . B, B , P P T T O p, pp . T p p--p : p p . W , p : . W p .
6
T“W”L McKENNA
“There are three rules to writing, and nobody knows what they are .” — W. Somerset Maugham
Thisi This is sa aqu quot ote efr from omo one neo off t the het tw wen enti tiet eth hce cent ntur ury’ y’sbe s besst storytellers,andIuseittokeepmyselfhumbleasateacher.I don’tknowhowanyonecreatesart.It’samysterythatrequires inspiration,hardworkandsomethingindenablethatcan’tbe learnedbyfollowingrulesfromabook(Icanhearmypublisher groaning…). T hankfully, craftsmanship (if not ar tistr y) can be taught.Ithashardrulesthatbecomemalleableunderanartist’stouch.So ist’ stouch.Soawiseartistgoesthrough“basictrainin awiseartistgoesthrough“basictraining” g”with with thoserulesbeforetoyingwiththem. How Ho wever, ,iits seeems mst to obe bet thhew waay yoft ofthe hew wor orlld dttha hattu unninitiatedwould-beartistsdi initiatedw ould-beartistsdiverightinwith verightinwithoutsubmitti outsubmittingto ngto this“basictraining”incraftsmanship. My drama school classmates and I were not part rtiicularlywisein larl ywiseinthematterof thematterof training. training.W Wewereactingstudent ewereactingstudents, s, filledwithpassionateimpulsesandskepticalabouttheneed forwisdom.Wewouldperformscenesforourteacher,filled withyouthfulbrioandgoodintentions.Mostofourwork wasprettycrappy. Having suered through our work, that teacher would begineachcritiquesessionwith begineach critiquesessionwithasimplequestion:“Whatdoes asimplequestion:“Whatdoes yourcharacterwant?”Dozensofsceneswouldbeperformed
7
Memo from the Story Department ~ Vogler & McKenna
throughoutthesemester,andthequestionwasposedevery singletime. single time.W Withoutfail, ithoutfail,theresponsew theresponsewasalotof asalotof hemming andhawingfromusstudents. andhawingfromusstu dents.W Wewereprettyhilariousinour insistentignorance. It’’s It sa ale leggac acy yth that atc con onti tinu nues es. .I’ I’vve eta taug ught htm my ysh shar are eofa ofact ct-ingclassesandhaveseenhundredsofactingscenes.Asmy teachers teac hers didbefor didbefore e me,I almo almost stal alwa ways ysask: ask: “Whatdo yo you u wanthere?” want here?”AsI AsIandmyclas andmyclassmatesdiddecadesago smatesdiddecadesago,mystu,mystudentslookattheirshoesandmumblesomethingalongthe linesof“Idunno.” So, in the name of basic training in craftsmanship, I want youand I (m (most ostly ly you) to mak make e upa lis list tof of “w “want ants. s.” Since Sin ce we kno know w tha that t the que quest stion ion wil will l be ask asked ed eve very ry si sing ngle le time,wewilllooklike“A”studentsifweatleasthavesome sortofanswer. So, So ,w wha hat tdo do pe peop ople le“w “wan ant” t”? ?W We eca can nst start art wi with th th the eba basi sics cs:: food,clothing,shelter.Canw food,clothing,shelter .Canwemake emakeupastoryaboutthesebaupastoryaboutthesebasicdesires?Idon’tseewhynot.Isn’tthedesireforallthreethe issuethatdrivestheheroesofBlakeEdwards’Victor/Victoria? We can open things up from there. Alcoholics want booze;justaskNicholasCagefrom Leaving Las Vegas .Sinners .Sinners wantredemption.Almostallofusyearnforloveandrecognition. Braveheart’s WilliamWallacelaiditallonthelinefor WilliamWallacelaiditallonthelinefor freedomand,afteralltheseyears,MickJaggerstillcan’tget nosatisfaction. In case we’ve forgotten, Cyndi Lauper inform rmss us that girlsjustwanttohavefun. Inf In fac act, t,p pop ops son ongs gsa are rea av virt irtua ual lte text xtbo book oko off “w “wan ants ts..” Th The e kidsfrom Fame “wa “want ntto toliv live efor forev ever. er.” Areth Aretha awan wants tsR-E-S-P R-E-S-P-E-C-T,andin Some Like It Hot ,MarilynMonroewantsto“be ,MarilynMonroewantsto“be lovedbyyou,justyouandnobodyelsebutyou.”InMarilyn’s case,itlookslikeasweetyen.ButgiveittoGlennClosein Fatal Attraction,andthesimple“want”getsdownrightscary. Micha Mic hael elCor Corleo leone ne wan ants ts fa famil milyy,,an and dhe he’’s swil willi ling ngto to kil kill lto to secureit.That’shistragedy,right?Howmanyofusjustyearn
8
The “WanT” LisT
fora for amat mate eand and kids kids? ?Whatdrama Whatdramatic tic acti actionwoul onwould dwe we tak take eto to acquiresuchthings? It’spr sprob obab ably ly no not tpo poli lite te to sa say yso so,,bu but tmo most st of us ar are ewi will llin ing g tomakedamnedfoolsofourselvestofullloursexual“wants.” Andhowaboutthesupportingcharacte Andhowabo utthesupportingcharacterinMaryChase’ rinMaryChase’scomedy scomedy Harveywhojustwantstositunderatreewithsomebeeranda girlwhopatshishandsaying“there,there”?Itdoesn’tseemlike much,butitfeedsanentire“B”plot. Moneydr driivesm moostofus ofust tooso som mede degr greeeor oro otther,an and d JamesBondwouldn’thavemuchtodounlessanendlessstream ofbadguyswantedtodominatetheworld.Jameshimselfseems satisedwithabottomlesssupplyofexoticcigarettes,devastating femmefatalesandmartinisshaken,notstirred.Cometothink ofit,Iwantthosethings,too. Sport Sp orts ste team ams sw wan ant tto tow win inc cha hamp mpio ions nshi hips ps, ,an and dhu hund ndrred edss oflmsrecordwhattheysacricetoaccomplishit. Alm Al moste evvery ryB Brroadwaym mus usic icaalo op pensw wiitha ann“I “Iw waant” song. son g. It’ It’s s the ant anthem hem dec declari laring ng the her hero’ o’s s des desire ire tha that t will be shapedandtestedbytheensuingaction.Bellefrom Beauty and the Beast musicallyyearnsforalifeofadventureliketheonesin musicallyyearnsforalifeofadventureliketheonesin thebooksshereads.ElizaDool thebooksshe reads.ElizaDoolittlefro ittlefrom m My Fair Ladywantsa “loverly”roomsomewherewithoneenormouschair.Thesong “OmigodYouGuys”fromLegally Blonde tellsusthatElleWoods tellsusthatElleWoods wantstomarryWarner,andtherestofthestorychasesthat desire. Are Ar eth ther ere emo more re“w “wan ants ts”? ”?I I ha havve eto to th thin ink kso so..Ca Carree eer rad advvan ance ce-ment,honor,recognition,victory,home,worldpeace,friendship, serenity,solitude,knowledge,wisdom,insight,answers,communionwithGod.Thelistgoesonandon,andeveryitemonit couldbethefoundationforasolidstory. For oru ussa asss sttor oryt ytel elle lers rs, ,tthe he“w “wan antt”l lis ist tbe beco come messa ap pri rima mary ry devicetobecontinuallysharpenedandkeptnearathandinour craftsmantoolbox.Astorydoesn’tevengetstarteduntilsomebodywantssomethingandmovesinadirectiontogetit.Your writinghasanimmediateadvantageifyouhaveacharacter “want”atyourfingertips. 9
Memo from the Story Department ~ Vogler & McKenna
Jus ust tto to be he help lpfu ful, l, I Ias askked a agro group up ofm ofmy yre rece cent nt st stud uden ents ts tobuilda“want”listwithme.I’llattachitbelow.Butgetto workonyourownpersonallist,too.Onceyou’vegotit,putit inyourtoolboxandputittowork.
Love Money Pleasure Validation (Approval) Security Revenge Stability Power Victory Freedom Acceptance Fame Redemption Respect Adventure God Truth Justice America Amer icann Way Way Change Attention Peace Sex Happiness Family Immortality Communication Survival
Knowledge Wisdom Drugs Escape Good Story Talent Stability Certainty Home Normalcy Excitement Inspiration Fun Independence To Forget To Remember Legacy Progress Forgiveness Friendship Death Fashion/Beauty Control Identity Company/Companionship Solitude Adrenaline/Rush Rock ’n’ Roll (see Drugs, Sex)
10
The “WanT” LisT
NOTE FROM VOGLER
Isat Isa tin ino on non one eofDa ofDavi vid’ d’sCo s Colu lumb mbia iac cla lassse ses srrec ecen enttly yan and d joinedhimandhisstudentsincritiquingscreenplayscenesthey hadwritten.Overandoverwehadthesamequestion:What doesthischaract does thischaracterwant? erwant?Untilthatisdetermined,scriptsand Untilthatisdetermined,scriptsand scenesseemwishy-washy scenesseemwishy-w ashy,disorganized,andspineless. ,disorganized,andspineless. Iha I havve em my yoown wnv ver ersi sion ono off t the he Wan ant tLi List st, ,a ahi hier erar arcchy yof of thingsthatdriveusthroughlife.Wemaynotrealizeitbut weareallrunningourlivesaccordingtocertainprimedirectives,chosenfromastandardlistofwishesthatexistinevery persontosomedegree.Eachperson,andeachcharacterina story sto ry,, cons consciou ciousl sly y or mor more e ofte often n unco unconsci nsciousl ouslyy, has ch chose osen n fromthelistonedrivethatcommand fromthelistonedri vethatcommandshisbehavio shisbehaviorabo raboveall veall others.Otherdrivesarepresentindescendingorderofimportance,butonedriveusuallydominates.Forexample,above all,Imusthavemyway,Imustbeinconspicuousatallcosts,I mustalwayshavethelastword,Imustbeseenashavingalot ofmoney,Imustfeelsecureandincontrolatalltimes,Imust bedifferentfromeveryoneelse,etc. Stor St orie ies sse seem em to be in inte tere rest sted ed in th thes ese eccho hoic ices es, ,an and dof ofte tenn set se t out to fo forc rce e a pr prota otago goni nist st to co cons nscio ciousl usly y re re-as -asse sess ss tha that t habitual habi tual,uncons ,unconsciou cioushierar shierarch chyof yof dri drives ves.At .Attheendof theendof the story,someonewhoputthedriv story ,someonewhoputthedrivetowinabov etowinaboveallmaycome eallmaycome toeditthelist,bringinganotherdrivetotheforeliketheneed forloveorfriendship.Inmyownlife,myprimedirectivefor manyyearswas“Everyonemustlikeme,”whichmeantthatI mustneverdoan mustnev erdoanythingtoupsetan ythingtoupsetanyone,and yone,andmustpleaseothmustpleaseothersevenattheexpenseofharmingmyself.Thestoryofmy lifehasconspiredtoteachmealesson—thedesiretoplease othersisagoodqualityinitsproperplacebutit’salousyway torun yo yourentir urentirelife. elife. I’ I’ve ve learned tobe tobehapp happywithmyse ywithmyself lf andletotherpeoplelovemeorhatemeastheychoose.
11