TUGAS PROPOSAL METODOLOGI PENELITIAN BISNIS
PENGARUH RASIO CAMEL TERHADAP TERHADAP PRAKTIK MANAJEMEN LABA DI BANK SYARIAH
TUGAS PROPOSAL Mata kuliah Metodoloi Pe!elitia! Bi"!i"
Di"u"u! Oleh #
DEDI ABDUL MAKKI (2090810003)
JURUSAN MANAJEMEN FAKULTAS EKONOMI UNIVERSITAS ISLAM MALANG 2010
DA$TAR ISI DA$TAR ISI………………………………………………………i
Abs!"#si…………………………………………………………$1 BAB I PENDAHULUAN
1$1 L""! B%&"#"'………………………………$$…$$……2 1$2 R*s"' M"s"&"+…………………$$……………,,……3 1$3 T-"' ."' M"'/"" %'%&ii"'………………………$…$$3 BAB II TINJAUAN TEORI DAN HIPOTESIS 2$1 "si& %'%&ii"' T%!."+&……………………………… 2$2 Ti'-""' T%!i…………………………………………$$ 2$2$1 %'%!i"' B"'# S4"!i"+……………………………… 2$2$2 2$2$3 2$2$
J%'is5J%'is B"'# U** S4"!i"+……………………$6 J%'is5J%'is U'i Us"+" S4"!i"+…………………$$…6 i7%sis …………………………………………$$$ BAB III METODOLOGI PENELITIAN 3$1 J%'is, L#"si ."' "# %'%&ii"'…………………$……8 3$1$1 -%'is 7%'%&ii"'………………………………………$$8 3$1$2 L#"si %'%&ii"'………………………………………8 3$1$3 "# %'%&ii"'…………………………………$……8 3$2 77&"si ."' S"*7%&………………………$……………9 3$2$1 7&"si………………………………………………9 3$2$2 S"*7%&………………………………………$$………9 3$3 D%/i'isi O7%!"si'"& V"!i"b%&……………………………$9 3$ S*b%! ."' M%.% %'*7&"' D""………………$$10 3$$1 S*b%! D""…………………………………………10 3$$2 M%.% %'*7&"' D""…………………………$$$10 3$6 M%.% A'"&isis D""……………$……………………10 DAFTAR USTAKA……………………………………$$11
A%"t&a't
T+% 7!7s% / +is s.4 is i':%si"% %"!'i's *"'"%*%' i' s4"!i" b"'#s "'. +% %//%; /
;'sis / S4"!i" B"'# (B"'# U** S4"!i"+ = BUS) "'. 18 S4"!i" Bssi'%s U'i (U'i Us"+" S4"!i"+ = UUS) " 4%"!s 2005200>$ O! !%s&s s+? +" ' ":%!"% +%!% is ' si'i/i;"' %"!'i's *"'"%*%' 7!";i;%s (*%"s!%. si' .is;!%i'"!4 ";;;!"&s) i' s4"!i" b"'#, "'.
Ke()o&d" # "(a&ia %a!k"* di"'&etio!a&( a''&ual"* ea&!i!" +a!ae+e!t* CAMEL &atio",
A%"t&ak"i
T-"' 7%'%&ii"' i'i "."&"+ '# *"'"-%*%' &"b" 7"." b"'# s4"!i"+ I':%si"si ."' 7%'"!+ !"si
Us"+"
S4"!i"+
=
UUS)
7"."
"+'
2005200>$
"si& #"*i *%''-##"' b"+?" !""5!"" i."# "." 7!"#%# *"'"-%*%' si'i/i#"' &"b" (.i#! .%'"' *%''"#"' "#!"& .is#!%si'%!) .i b"'# s4"!i"+, ."' !"si
Kata ku!'i # Ba!k S(a&iah* ak&ual dik&e"io!e&* +a!a-e+e! la%a* &a"io CAMEL,
BAB I PENDAHULUAN
.,. Lata& Belaka!
I'/!*"si "#'"'si 4"' %!s"-i ."&"* &"7!"' #%"'"' *%!7"#"' s"&"+ s" i'/!*"si "*" 4"' ."7" .i"#s%s &%+ i':%s!, #!%.i! *"7' 7%*%"' s"+"* '# *%'i&"i #i'%!-" *"'"-%! ."&"* *%'%&&" ."'" 7%!s"+""'$ M"'"-%! ."7" s"-" *%&"##"' 7!"#i# *"'"-%*%' &"b" (earnings management ) '# -"' %!%'$ %"&4 (1986), K"7&"' (1986), M; Ni;+&s "'. Ni&&s' (1988), ."' &+"s%', L"!;#%!, "'. S&"' (1996) *%'%*#"' b#i "."'4" i'."#"' *"'"-%! ."&"* *%&"##"' *"'"-%*%' &"b" %!"*" 4"' %!#"i .%'"' !"'s"#si accrual $ !"#i# *"'"-%*%' &"b" i'i -" .i%*#"' .i s%#! 7%!b"'#"' s%7%!i !bb (1998) 4"' *%'."7"#"' b#i "."'4" i'.i#"si 7%'%&&""' &"b" 7"." s%#! 7%!b"'#"'$ %'%&ii"' B%!!"'. (2000) *%'%*#"' b#i s%;"!" %*7i!is b"'# .i S?iss 4"' s%.i#i #!"' "" *%'.%#"i #%%'"' b""s"' #%;#7"' *."& ;%'.%!' '# *%'i'#"#"' !"si #%;#7"' *."& (
#%s%+""''4"
;%'.%!'
*%&"##"' earnings
management $ Ss"' (2003) *%'%*#"' "."'4" i'.i#"si 7!"#i# 7%'%&&""' &"b" ( earnings management ) 4"' .i&"##"' &%+ #%&*7# b"'# i."# s%+" ."' s"&"+ s" /"#! .*i'"' 4"' *%'.!' b"'# *%&"##"' 7%'%&&""' &"b" %!s%b "."&"+ *i/ *%'i'#"#"' #i'%!-" b"'#$ E'.!i"'i (200) *%'%*#"' "."'4" i'.i#"si earnings management 7"." b"'# ."&"* s"+" *%*%'+i #%%'"' #%;#7"' ) -" *%'%*#"' "."'4" i'.i#"si 7!"#i# *"'"-%*%' &"b" .%'"' ;"!" *%'i'#"#"' &"b" 7"." 7%!b"'#"' '"si'"& 7"s;" 7!"* !%#"7i"&is"si$
B"'# s4"!i"+ s"&"+ s" b%'# 7%!"si'"& b"'# 4"' "." .i I'.'%si", .i*"'" s%7%!i b"'# #':%'si'"&, b"'# s4"!i"+ -" %!i#" .%'"' 7%!"!"' b"i# 4"' .i%"7#"' &%+ 7%*%!i'"+ *"7' b"'# I'.'%si" (BI) s%b""i b"'# s%'!"& .i I'.'%si", ."' .i"*b"+ .%'"' "!"' s4"!i"+$ %'i&"i"' #i'%!-" b"'# s4"!i"+ -" i."# -"+ b%!b%." .%'"' b"'# #':%'si'"&$ .,/ Ru+u"a! Ma"alah
B%!."s"!#"' !"i"' 4"' %&"+ .i#%*#"#"' .i ""s, *"#" !*s"' 7%!*"s"&"+"' ."&"* 7%'%&ii"' i'i "."&"+ 1)$ A7"#"+ %!."7" i'.i#"si 7!"#i# *"'"-%*%' &"b" 7"." b"'# s4"!i"+C 2) A7"#"+ #i'%!-" b"'# s4"!i"+ .%'"' !"si
.,0 Tu-ua! da! Ma!1aat Pe!elitia! 1$3$1 T-"' %'%&ii"'
1$ U'# *%&i+" i'.i#"si 7!"#i# *"'"-%*%' &"b" 4"' .i7%'"!+i &%+ #i'%!-" 7"." b"'# s4"!i"+$ 1$3$2 M"'/"" %'%&ii"' "si& 7%'%&ii"' i'i .i+"!"7#"' ."7" *%*b%!i#"' i'/!*"si #%7"." 7%''" &"7!"' #%"'"' '# *%'%'"i "7"#"+ %!."7" i'.i#"si *"'"-%*%' &"b" .i b"'# s4"!i"+, s%+i'" 7%''" ."7" &%bi+ %&ii ."&"* *%*b";" &"7!"' #%"'"'$
BAB II TINJAUAN TEORI DAN HIPOTESIS
/,. Ha"il Pe!elitia! Te&dahulu
B%b%!"7" 7%'%&ii"' 7"." b"'# #':%'si'"& .i I'.'%si", *%''-##"' "."'4" i'.i#"si 7!"#i# *"'"-%*%' &"b" (eanings management ) s%7%!i 7%'%&&ii"' 4"' .i&"##"' &%+ S%i"?"i ."' N"i* (2001), Ss"' (2003) E'.!i"'i (200) ."' A!'"?" (200>)$ J" *%'%*#"' "."'4" i'.i#"si 7!"#i# *"'"-%*%' &"b" .%'"' ;"!" *%'i'#"#"' &"b" 7"." 7%!b"'#"' '"si'"& 7"s;" 7!!"* !%#"7i"&is"si$ B"'# s4"!i"+ 4"' ."&"* 7%!"si'"&'4"
*%*i&i#i /'si 4"' &%bi+ &"s ."!i b"'# #':%'si'"& s%7%!i 4"' .i"!"i#"' ."&"* 7%.*"' "#'"'si 7%!b"'#"' s4"!i"+ I'.'%si" (ASI) 2003 4"i s%b""i *"'"-%! i':%s"si, i':%s!, 7%'4%.i" -"s" #%"'"' ."' &"& &i'"s 7%*b"4"!"', s%!" 7%'%*b"'"' /'si ssi"&$ K+"' (1992), ."&"* S/i% (2006) *%'i.%'i/i#"si#"' -"' &"7!"' #%"'"' "#'"'si s4"!i"+ "'"!" &"i' "."&"+ 7%'%'"' &"b" !i 4"' %7" ."' *%&"7!#"' .%'"' "."7"b&% %!+"."7 7%!b"+"'$ S4"+""+ (2001) *%*b"i -"' "#'"'si #%'"' (&"7!"' #%"'"') .i"'"!"'4" *%*b"' 7%'"*bi&"' #%7s"' 4"' &%bi+ b"i# ."' *%'%'#"' b%s"!'4" 7%'+"si&"' 4"' ?"-ib .i "#"i$ %'%&ii"' E'.!i"'i (200) .i%*#"' b"+?" b"'# *%&"##"' earnings management ."&"* 7"4" *%*%'+i #%%'"' !"si #%;#7"' *."& *i'i** (
/,/ Ti!-aua! Teo&i /,/,. Pe!e&tia! Ba!k S(a&iah
B"'# s4"!i"+ "."&"+ b"'# 4"' ."&"* "#i:i"s'4", b"i# 7%'+i*7'"' ."'" ."' *"7' ."&"* !"'#" 7%'4"&!"' ."'"'4" *%*b%!i#"' ."' *%'%'"#"' i*b"&"' ""s ."s"! 7!i'si7 s4"!i"+ 4"i -"& b%&i ."' b"i +"si&$ D"&"* *%'-"&"'#"' #%i""' 7%!"si'"&'4", b"'# s4"!i"+ i."# *%''"#"' sis%* b'" ."&"* *%'%'#"' i*b"&"' ""s ."'" 4"' .i'"#"' "" .iii7#"' &%+ s" 7i+"#$ %'%'"' i*b"&"' %!+"."7 ."'" 4"' .i7i'-"*#"' *"7' ."'" 4"' .isi*7"' .i b"'# .i."s"!#"' 7"." 7!i'si7 b"i +"si& s%s"i .%'"' +#* is&"*$
/,/,/ Je!i"2Je!i" Ba!k U+u+ S(a&iah
1$ B"'# M"*"&" I'.'%si" (BMI) 2$ B"'# S4"!i"+ M"'.i!i (BSM) 3$ B"'# S4"!i"+ I'.'%si"
/,/,0 Je!i"2Je!i" U!it U"aha S(a&iah
1$ B"'# IFI S4"!i"+ 2$ B"'# D"'"*' S4"!i"+ 3$ BRI S4"!i"+ $ B"'# Ni"" S4"!i"+ 6$ B"'# %!*"" S4"!i"+ >$ BNI S4"!i"+ $ BII S4"!i"+ 8$ B"'# Ri" S4"!i"+ 9$ B"'# J"b"! S4"!i"+ 10$ BD S* S4"!i"+ 11$ BD DKI S4"!i"+ 12$ BD L*b# NTB 13$ BD A;%+ S4"!i"+ 1$ BD K"&s%& S4"!i"+ 16$ SB< S4"!i"+ 1>$ BTN S4"!i"+ K"!%'" 7%'i&"i"' #i'%!-" b"'# s4"!i"+ **'4" i."+ -"+ b%!b%." .%'"' b"'# #':%'si'"&, *"#" .i." 7%'i&"i"' #i'%!-" b"'# s4"!i"+ .%'"' !"si
R"si < (Capital ) 7"." !"si ) *%''"#"' !"si Return On Assets
(ROA) s%b""i s"&"+ s" 7!#si '# *%'i&"i #i'%!-" b"'#$ Di*"'" 'i&"i !"si ROA 4"' !%'."+ -" .i." "#"' &%bi+ *%*i:"si b"'# '# *%&"##"' *"'"-%*%' &"b" .%'"' ;"!" *%'i'#"#"' &"b"$ R"si E (earning ) 7"." !"si
/,/ Hi4ote"i"
B%!."s"!#"' 7%'%&ii"' %!."+& ."' i'-""' %!i, *"#" +i7%sis ."&"* 7%'%&ii"' i'i "."&"+ s%b""i b%!i# 1 T%!."7" i'.i#"si 7!"#i# *"'"-%*%' &"b" b"'# s4"!i"+ 2" R"si
BAB III METODOLOGI PENELITIAN 0,. Je!i"* Loka"i da! 5aktu Pe!elitia! 0,.,. -e!i" 4e!elitia!
U'# *%'-i i'.i#"si 7!"#i# *"'"-%*%' &"b" 7"." +i7%sis 1 (1) .i ""s .i'"#"' -i b%.", 4"i "7"#"+ !""5!"" 'i&"i AD 7"." b"'# s4"!i"+ 0$ i7%si 2 .i-i .%'"' *%''"#"' !%!%si b%!"'." .%'"' *.%& s%b""i b%!i# ADi H ɪ BUSi H D%'"' %#s7%#"si 1 ˂ 0, 2 ˂ 0, ɜ ˂ 0, ˂ 0 ."' 6
˂0
Di*"'" ADi
A#!"& Dis#!%si'%! ("#!"& "b'!*"&) b"'# s4"!i"+ I 7"." "+'
'i&"i !"si
RORAi
'i&"i !"si RORA (return on Risked Assets) b"'# s4"!i"+ I 7"." "+'
NMi
'i&"i !"si NM ( Net Profit Margin) b"'# s4"!i"+ I 7"." "+'
ROAi
'i&"i ROA ( Return On Assets) b"'# s4"!i"+ I 7"." "+'
LDRi
'i&"i !"si LDR ( Loan to Deposit Ratio) b"'# s4"!i"+ I 7"." "+'
BUSi
'i&"i D**4 b"'# s4"!i"+ i 7"." "+' , .i*"'" 1 BUS ."' 0 UUS
"." *.%& !%!%si .i ""s -" .i*"s#"' :"!i"b%& #'!& BUS 4"' *"#s.#"' '# *%''!& #%*'#i'"' "."'4" 7%!b%.""' "#!"& .is#!%si'%! "'"!" b"'# s4"!i"+ 4"' b%!b%'# BUS .%'"' %#s7#"si > 0$
0,.,/ Loka"i Pe!elitia!
%'%&ii"' .i&"##"' 7"." 7%!b"'#"' s4"!i"+ .i I'.'%si" .%'"' 7%'"*bi&"' ."" 7"." &"7!"' #%"'"' 7b&i#"si "+'"' b"'# s4"!i"+ 4"' ."7" .i7%!&%+ ."!i *%.i" *"ss" 4"' *%*" 7b&i#"si %!s%b ""7' ."!i Di!%#!i %!b"'#"' I'.'%si" 4"' .i%!bi#"' &%+ BI s%!" ."!i ?%bsi% BI ???$bi$$i.$ 0,.,0 5aktu Pe!elitia!
"# 7%'%&ii"' i'i .i&"##"' 7"." b&"' M%i "+' 200 +i'" s%&%s"i$
0,/ 4o4ula"i da! Sa+4el 0,/,. Po4ula"i
M%'! I'.!i"'! ."' S7* (1999116) 7&"si "."&"+ s%#%&*7# !"', #%-".i"' "" s%"&" s%s" 4"' *%*7'4"i #"!"#%!isi# %!%'$ A'" ."!i 77&"si %!s%b s%b""i %&%*%' 77&"si ( population element )$ D"&"* 7%'%&ii"' i'i 77&"si 4"' .i%&ii "."&"+ s%*" 7%!b"'#"' s4"!i"+ .i I'.'%si", 4"' b%!."s"!#"' ."" BI b&"' M%i "+' 200$ 0,/,/ Sa+4el
S"*7%& #"*i %!.i!i ."!i 21 b"'# s4"!i"+, %!.i!i ."!i b"'# s4"!i"+ (B"'# U** S4"!i"+ = BUS) ."' 18 'i s4"!i"+ bsi'%s ('i Us"+" S4"!i"+ = UUS) 7"." "+' 2005 200>$ 0,0 De1i!i"i O4e&a"io!al 6a&ia%el
D%/i'isi 7%!"si'"& "."&"+ 7%'%' constuct s%+i'" *%'-".i :"!i"b%& 4"' ."7" .i#!, .%/i'isi 7%!"si'"& *%'-%&"s#"' ;"!" %!%' 4"' .i'"#"' &%+ 7%'%&ii ."&"* *%'7%!"si#"' construct , s%+i'" *%*'#i'#"' b"i 7%'%&ii 4"' &"i' '# *%&"##"' !%7&i#"si 7%'#!"' .%'"' ;"!" 4"' s"*" "" *%'%*b"'#"' ;"!" 7%'#!"' ;'s!; 4"' &%bi+ b"i# (I'.!i"'! ."' S7*, 2002>9)$
V"!i"b%&5:"!i"b%& ."&"* 7%'%&ii"' i'i "."&"+ s%b""i b%!i# 1$
B"'# S4"!i"+ B"'# s4"!i"+ "."&"+ b"'# 4"' ."&"* "#i:i"s'4", b"i# 7%'+i*7'"' ."'" ."'
*"7' ."&"* !"'#" 7%'4"&!"' ."'"'4" *%*b%!i#"' ."' *%'%'"#"' i*b"&"' ""s ."s"! 7!i'si7 s4"!i"+ 4"i -"& b%&i ."' b"i +"si&$ 2$ A#!"& Dis#!%si'%! %'+i'"' "& "#!"& s"*" .%'"' 4"' .i&"##"' %"&4 (1986) ."' J'%s (1991) 4"' %&"+ .is%s"i#"' .%'"' #"!"%!isi# 7%!b"'#"', .%'"' !*s TAi (MADi H BDDi H UMi 5 BDi 5 Ui 5 BAi D%7i)=(Ai5 1) Di*"'" TAi "& "#!"& b"'# s4"!i"+ i 7"." "+' , MADi s%&isi+ 7%'."7""' *"si+ "#"' .i%!i*" b"'# s4"!i"+ I 7"." "+' .%'"' 51, BDDi s%&isi+ b%b"' .ib"4"! .i*#" b"'# s4"!i"+ I 7"." "+' .%'"' 51, UMi s%&isi+ "' 7"-"# b"'# s4"!i"+ I 7"." "+' .%'"' 51, BDi s%&isi+ b%b"' 4"' +"!s .ib"4"! b"'# s4"!i"+ I 7"." "+' .%'"' 51, Ui s%&isi+ "' 7"-"# b"'# s4"!i"+ I 7"." "+' .%'"' 51, BAi b%b"' 7%'4isi+"' "#i:" 7!.#i/ b"'# s4"!i"+ I 7"." "+' , D%bi b%b"' .%7!%si"si b"'# s4"!i"+ I 7"." "+' , Ai5 1 "& "#i:" b"'# s4"!i"+ I 7"." "+' 51$ K%*.i"', .i&"##"' %si*"si .%'"' *%''"#"' *.%& TAi= Ai51 "ɪ (1= Ai51) H b ɪ (Oi= Ai51) H b2(Ei= Ai51) H ɛᵢ Di*"'" TAi "& "#!"& b"'# s4"!i"+ i 7"." "+' , Ai51 "& "#i:" b"'# s4"!i"+ i 7"." "+' , Oi s%&isi+ 7%'."7""' 7%!"si'"& s4"!i"+ i 7"." "+' .%'"' 51, Ei property plant and equipment ("#i:" %"7) b"'# s4"!i"+ i 7"." "+' , 7%!#i!""' error (ɛᵢ) ."&"* 7%!s"*""' .i ""s *%''-##"' "#!"& .is#!%si'%! ( discretionary)$ 3$
R"si
RORA &"b" s%b%&* 7"-"#="#i:" 7!.#i/, .i*"'" "#i:" 7!.#i/ "."&"+ s%*" "#i:" b"i# ."&"* !7i"+ *"7' :"&" "si' 4"' .i*i&i#i b"'# s4"!i"+ .%'"' *"#s. '# *%*7%!&%+ 7%'+"si&"' s%s"i .%'"' /'si'4"P management .i#! .%'"' RORA &"b" b%!si+="& "#i:"P Earnings .i#! .%'"' NM &"b" 7%!"si=7%'."7""'P ."' Liquidity .i#! .%'"' LDR -*&"+ #!%.i 4"' .ib%!i#"'=-*&"+ ."'" 7i+"# #%i"$ 0,7 Su+%e& da! Metode Pe!u+4ula! Data 0,7,. Su+%e& Data S*b%! ."" 4"' .i'"#"' ."&"* 7%'%&ii"' i'i "."&"+ ."" .%'"' M.%& !%!%si 4"' *%''"#"' *%.% %si*"si Ordinary Least "quares (OLS) "#"' *%*b%!i#"' +"si& 4"' #est Linear $n%iased ."' Estimator (BLUE) -i#" *%*%'+i s%*" "s*si #&"si#$ %'-i"' +i7%sis 1 (1) .i&"##"' .%'"' -i b%."$ 0,7,/ Metode Pe!u+4ula! Data
D"" 4"' "#"' .i&"+ ."&"* 7%'%&ii"' i'i .i"*bi& ."!i &"7!"' #%"'"' 7b&i#"si "+'"' b"'# s4"!i"+$ 0,8 Metode A!ali"i" Data
T%'i# ."&"* 7%'%&ii"' i'i "."&"+ "'"&isis .is#!i*i'"'$ D"&"* +"& i'i '# *%'i':%si"si 7!"#i# *"'"-%*%' &"b" .i b"'# s4"!i"+$
DA$TAR PUSTAKA
A!'"?", I G%.% (200>)$ A'"&is" I'.i#"si M"'"-%*%' L"b" *%&%&i Dis;!%i'"!4 A&&?"';% /! L"' Ls%s 7"." %!b"'#"' "s;" R%#"7i"&is"si$ K"!4" A#+i! !!"* M"is%! A#'"'si F"#&"s E#'*i U'i:%!si"s I'.'%si", J"#"!"$ B%!!"'., Ri*", S?iss N"i'"& B"'# (2000)$ <"7i"& R%Qi!%*%' "'. B"'# B%+":i! E*7%!i;"& E:i.%';% /! S?i%!&"'.$ !#i' "7%!$ B%4, A''%$ L "'. %!'i, K"+4$ R (2002)$ E"!'i's M"'"%*%' A:i. E"!'i's D%;&i'%s A;!ss b&i;4 "'. !i:"% +%&. B"'#, T+% A;;'i' R%:i%?, V& $ E'.!i"'i, D (200)$ I'.i#"si !"#%# E"!'i's M"'"%*%' &%+ B"'#5B"'# .i I'.'%si" D"&"* M%*%'+i K%%'"' R"si K%;#7"' M."&$ K"!4" A#+i! !!"* M"is%! A#'"'si F"#&"s E#'*i U'i:%!si"s I'.'%si", J"#"!"$ %"&4, $M$ (1986)$ T+% E//%; / B's S;+%*%s ' A;;'i' D%;isi'$ J!'"& / A;;'i' "'. E;'*i; 86510$ J'%s, J$J$ (1991)$ E"!'i's M"'"%*%' D!i' I*7! !%&i%/ i':%si"i'$ J!'"& / A;;'i' R%s%"!;+ ( A*') 1935228$ M;Ni;+&"s, M$ "'. M$D$ N%i*"!# (1988)$ E:i.%';% / E"!'i's M"'"%*%' /!* +% !:isi' /! B". D%bs , J!'"&s / A;;'i' R%s%"!;+ ( S77&%*%' 1988), 77
3356$
N";i!i, A+*%. (2002)$ E"!'i's M"'"%*%' /!* B"'# !:isi's /! L"'s &ss%s$ !#i' "7%!, J"'"!4$
N"ss%!, E4 M$ (2003)$ %!b"'.i'"' Ki'%!-" B"'# %*%!i'"+ ."' B"'# S?"s" .%'"' !"si $ Rbb, S%"', $G$ (1998)$ T+% E//%;s / A'"&4ss F!%;"s% ' E"!'i's M"'"%*%' i' Fi'"';i"& I'sii's$ J!'"& / Fi'"';i"& R%s%"!;+ (F"&&)$ S%i"?"i, Li&is ."' N"i* Ai'' (2001)$ B"'# %"&+ E:"&"i' B4 B"'# I'.'%si" "'. E"!'i's M"'"%*%' i' B"'#i' I'.s!4$ G".-"+ M"." I'%!'"i'"& J!'"& / Bssi'%ss, M"4 2001, V& 3 ' 2 16951>$ S/i% (2006)$ M%!*s#"' T-"' L"7!"' K%"'"' B"'# S4"!i"+ S%b"+ S.i E#s7&!"si$ M%.i" Ris% A#'"'si, A.ii' ."' I'/!*"si, V& 6 N 1 A7!i&
2006
26539$ Ss"', As (2003)$ I'.i#"si !"#%# %'%&&""' L"b" ."' F"#!5F"#! 4"' M%*7%'"!+i'4" ( s.i E*7i!is 7"." S%#! %!b"'#"' S%b%&* K!isis N"si'"& ), K"!4" A#+i !!"* M"is%! A#'"'si F"#&"s
E#'*i
%!b"'#"' U'i:%!si"s
I'.'%si", J"#"!"$ 5 S%% *!% " +7==%!i;#5#%s%7i"'$b&s7$;*=2012=03="s57!7s"&5*%.&i5 7%'%&ii"'$+*&s+"s+$MN#N1.$.7/
